Received Date: October 15, 2016; Accepted Date: November 17, 2016; Published Date: November 23, 2016
Citation: Hori K, Hosoi M, Konishi K, Hachisu M, Tomioka H, et al. (2016) Pharmacotherapies for Behavioral and Psychological Symptoms of Dementia with Alzheimer’s Disease: Two Subcategories of these Symptoms. Brain Disord Ther 5: 225. doi: 10.4172/2168-975X.1000225
Copyright: © 2016 Hori K, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Visit for more related articles at Brain Disorders & Therapy
In this article, we reviewed our previous articles those showed that ageing process and disease progression connected affective disturbances and anxiety with delusion, hallucination and aggressiveness and those behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia (BPSD) is related with bipolarity (BT), and we comment the pharmacotherapies for BPSD in Alzheimer’s disease (AD). There are two types of BPSD with AD. One is related with the progressions of AD that is caused by the deteriorated lesions by AD pathology. Therefore, these symptoms are ameliorated by the treatment for AD, that is, cholinesterase inhibitors or N-methyl-D-aspartate receptors antagonist. The other is related with brain reserve (BR) and cognitive reserve (CR). In this pattern, the information processing system is not deteriorated. However, low BR caused by BT and low CR modulate the behaviors etwas eccentric. When lowering of brain volume caused by AD pathology is added, i.e., BR is lower than before, BPSD appears. Therefore, in this patter, SSRI, atypical antipsychotics and anticonvulsants those have the treatment option for bipolar disorders, galanatmine and SNRI are needed.
Brain reserve; Pharmacotherapies; Psychological symptoms; Alzheimer’s disease
AA: Anticholinergic Activity; Ach: Acetylcholine; AD: Alzheimer’s Disease; BPSD: Behavioral and Psychological Symptoms of Dementia; BR: Brain Reserve; BT: Bipolarity; CR: Cognitive Reserve; Pharmacotherapy; NMDA: N-methyl-D-Aspartate; ChEI: Cholinesterase Inhibitor; CR: Cognitive Reserve; HP: Higher Performance; HP: Lower Performance
We previously reported that aging process  and disease progression of Alzheimer’s disease (AD)  connected depressive symptoms (affective disturbance and anxiety) with psychotic symptoms such as delusion, hallucination and aggressiveness. These features are mixed state of manic state and depressive state, therefore, there might be relationship between bipolarity (BT)  and psychological symptoms of dementia (BPSD) in AD [4,5]. From these reports, we considered that BPSD in AD should be treated as “augmentation” (pharmacotherapy for bipolar disorder) . In this previous article, we proposed the reasonability of prescribing the atypical antipsychotics for BPSD in AD. However, in Japan, there are currently no licensed medicines for the management of BPSD in AD patients although in case of oldest old patient antidepressant is useful for ameliorating BPSD in AD . Moreover, although antipsychotics for BPSD are not inhibited and symptoms such as delusions, hallucinations, agitation, or aggression are prescribed with consent from the legal representatives of AD patients, there is a warning for prescription of atypical antipsychotics for demented patients because of the increased mortality rate in patients with AD . Therefore, it is important to propose the other reasonability to prescribe other psychotropics than antipsychotics for BPSD in AD.
In this article, we propose this reasonability mainly based on the other our previous article that we evaluate the relationship between bipolar temperament (BT) and BPSD in AD patients .
We evaluate the relationship between BT and BPSD in in 65 AD patients using demographic data (sex, educational level, age at dementia onset, age at the time of test and duration of illness), BP, cognitive function, existence of BPSD. BPSD was be related with BT. Lower educational level was related with BPSD among those with BT (p<0.05). From these results, we considered that brain reserve (BR) and cognitive reserve (CR) were related with some kinds of BPSD in AD and treatment of BT and heightening CR might prevent some kind of BPSD in AD . BR (or biological reserve) is brain volume or neuronal count that explains the individual differences of power against of inserts and those of real pathological structures . Because certain characters were reported to be related with brain structure  and hyperthymic and cyclothymic temperaments were reported to be related with bipolar disorder , we speculated that BT might be related with BR. On the contrary, CR (neural reserve) is defined as an ability to compensate for dysfunctions caused by pathological processes in central nervous system . Kartzman reported that education was one of the most important factors those attributed to CR . From these points of view, we speculated that on the base of poor BR, low CR caused BPSD in AD patients because BPSD in AD was related with BT and among those with BT lower educational level was related with BPSD .
On the contrary, we already evaluated the BPSD in 79 consecutive AD patients in view of dementia severity using behavioral pathology of Alzheimer’s disease . First, we investigated the correlation between cognitive function and the severity of dementia or each symptom domain of BPSD. Then the AD patients were divided into a group with higher performance (n=40, HP group) and a group with lower performance (n=39, LP group). Subsequently, we compared BPSD between these two groups and a factor analysis of BPSD was conducted in each group. We found that disturbance of activity and disturbance of diurnal rhythm were negatively correlated with cognitive function (p<0.05), while affective disturbance was positively correlated with cognitive function (p<0.05). Factor analysis showed that a mood cluster (affective disturbance plus anxieties and phobias) was associated with a psychiatric cluster (paranoid and delusional ideation plus hallucinations) and with aggressiveness in the LP group. These results indicate that disease progress of AD influences the BPSD of AD patients in two ways. That is, behavioral symptoms become more severe and the mood cluster conversely becomes milder but is connected to the psychiatric cluster and aggressiveness. Moreover, there were no differences of the age at the onset of dementia or age at testing between the LP group and the HP group. This means that the duration of AD was not a determinant of the performance of our patients. At least two possible explanations for this finding can be suggested that there may be two different causes of BPSD in AD patients. There were reported the two factors those were related with BPSD in AD [14,15]. Ito et al. reported that there are two independent pathophysiological processes contributing to BPSD in AD, one of which is associated with behavioral symptoms and overlaps with cognitive dysfunction, while the other is associated with psychological symptoms and is not related to cognitive dysfunction .
We adopt the theory to these two studies of ours [2,9] and BPSD in AD are mainly differentiated to two subcategories. One is overlap of psychotic and behavioral factors in the LP group, in which group the factor consisted of paranoid and delusional ideation, hallucination, aggressiveness, affective disturbances, and anxieties and phobias by rapid cognitive decline. The other causing psychotic symptoms along with slow cognitive decline related with BT and low CR. The patients in LP group had worse symptoms of dementia and showed more advanced BPSD within one year of the onset of behavioral symptoms. Therefore, AD patients may develop BPSD at either the mild stage or the severe stage of cognitive dysfunction, and there is a subset of AD patients who show rapid decline of cognitive function and possibly only manifest BPSD when there is a severe decrease of their cognitive function. However, there are some overlap symptoms between in those two subcategories and it is not ease to discriminate these two subcategories clearly. Therefore, we consider that there are mainly two categories in BPSD in AD. One is related with AD pathology, i.e., downregulation of acetylcholine (ACh). The other is related with depression or bipolar pathology, i.e., downregulation of serotonin. We divide BPSD in AD into two subcategories.
We show the two patterns of BPSD in AD in Figure 1. One is related with AD pathology. When the information processing system is deteriorated, of course behavior is deteriorated. The other is related with BR and CR. In this pattern, the information processing system is not deteriorated. However, low BR and low CR modulate the behavior etwas eccentric. When downregulation of brain volume caused by AD pathology is added, i.e., BR is lower than before, BPSD appears.
Figure 1(a-e): There are two types of BPSD with AD. One is related with the progressions of AD that is caused by the deteriorated lesions by AD pathology (Figure1a and 1b). The other is related with brain reserve (BR) and cognitive reserve (CR). In this pattern, the information processing system is not deteriorated. However, low BR and low CR modulate the behaviors etwas eccentric. When lowering of brain volume caused by AD pathology is added, i.e., BR is lower than before, BPSD appears (Figure 1c, 1d and 1e).
We consider that there are A, B, C, D and E in the treatment of BPSD in AD. A and D is the treatment of AD. These include cholinesterase inhibitors (ChEI) and N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptors antagonist. These agents are effective for symptoms with cholinergic related pathology (amyloid) and progression of AD such as wandering, apathy, delusion and hallucination. In fact, combinations of these agents are effective for BPSD . Moreover, we speculate that anticholinergic activity appears endogenously in AD at moderate stage, which might be related with downregulation of ACh, inflammation and upregulation of NMDA receptor activity [17,18]. When AA is burdened, BPSD such as visual hallucination, delusion and diurnal rhythm disturbance is tended to appear than cognitive dysfunction [19,20] such as memory disturbance [21-23], disorientation  and executive dysfunction . Therefore, it is also important to prescribe ChEI and NMDA receptor antagonist for prevention of the appearance of AA and delineation of AA .
B is the treatment of BR. As for the BPSD in AD, Two factors are related with downregulation of BR. One is BT and the other is reduction of brain volume caused by AD pathology. Therefore, SSRI, atypical antipsychotics and anticonvulsants those have the treatment option for bipolar disorders. Needless to say the effectiveness of agents are reported . Of course, ChEI are thought to be effective. However, upregulation of ACh causes depression and aggressiveness. Therefore, galanatmine is better for these symptoms because allosteric nicotinic receptor modulating action causes upregulation of serotonergic, GABAnergic and noradrenergic enhancing capacities .
C is the treatment of CR. As for the cognitive function educations, environment  and noradrenergic system  are included. Therefore, SNRI is effective for these symptoms. In fact, the effectiveness of SNRI is reported .
E is environment. The environmental factors are important to prevent BPSD. One is the stimulation that is processed by the system that is not deteriorated. The other is the stimulation that is heightening CR.
As the other important issue for BPSD in AD, we comment that it is difficult for differentiation of AD form Lewy body disease (LBD). It is relatively easy to diagnose as LBD when the visual hallucination is present. However, before the appearance of visual hallucination, dysfunction of parasympathetic nerve system is present, which corresponds to the prodromal stage of LBD. Therefore, symptoms related to dysfunction of the parasympathetic nervous system occur in LBD, such as REM behavioral symptoms, syncope, and constipation . Moreover, hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis hyperactivity gradually worsens at this stage caused by dysfunction of the parasympathetic nervous system . Therefore, we consider that depression, which is related to HPA axis hyperactivity also develops . We have already reported that anxiety and affective disturbances in AD patients are connected to delusion, hallucination, and aggressiveness by aging and the disease progress . Therefore, if the degree of ACh dysfunction is relatively large, depression appears as BPSD of dementia in AD. We should keep this concept in mind. If when we treat the elder patient with depression prescribing antidepressants with or without augmentation of medicines for depression and unfavorable or not favorable effects was seen, we should consider the diagnosis of this patient as LBD and prescribe Aricept for this patient, because this medicine is only permitted for LBD patients in Japan (since September 2014).